A gloved hand holding a Zabidou inline inspection unit on a plant walkway

Quality Assurance · Non-conformance

Non conformance in precast andsteel fabrication

A non-conformance is a departure from a specified requirement. An item, a process or a document does not meet what the drawing, the standard or the contract called for, and the departure is significant enough that it cannot simply be corrected quietly.

Once raised it has to be dispositioned. Somebody with the authority to decide rules that the item is used as it stands, reworked, repaired or rejected, and that decision is recorded. The record is usually called a non-conformance report, or NCR. Zabidou exists to keep faults on the other side of that line, catching a dimensional departure while the item is still on the bed and the fix is a correction rather than a report.

Zabidou in production today

QLD + VIC

Operating in factories across Queensland and Victoria today.

100%

Inspection coverage on finished items as they come off the line.

Silver

Associate Member, Australian Steel Institute.

Bronze

Member, National Precast Association Australia.

What makes a departure a non-conformance

Not every imperfection is a non-conformance. Three things have to be present before the term applies, and the absence of any one of them is the usual reason two parties disagree about whether one has occurred.

A specified requirement

01

There has to be a stated requirement to depart from: a dimension on a drawing, a clause in a specification, a tolerance in a standard or an approved sample. Preference is not a requirement.

An objective departure

02

The departure has to be demonstrable rather than a matter of opinion. A measurement against a tolerance settles it; a view about appearance usually does not, unless a finish class was specified.

A decision to be made

03

The item cannot continue as though nothing happened. Someone with authority has to decide its fate, and until they do the item is held.


What a non-conformance actually costs

The cost of a non-conformance is rarely the cost of the item. It is the cost of everything the item was holding up, and that grows with every step the item travels before anyone notices.

01

The item itself

Rework, repair or scrap, plus the materials and the line time already spent. On a precast element this is the smallest of the three costs and the easiest to quantify.

02

The programme around it

A held item delays what sits behind it. Where the element was due on site, the delay reaches the crane, the crew and the sequence, and the cost leaves the plant entirely.

03

The standing of the record

A non-conformance raised by a customer after delivery carries different weight from one raised in the plant. The first invites an audit of everything else; the second is evidence the system works.

Where a non-conformance is cheapest to find

The same departure costs a different amount depending on which side of the dispatch gate it is discovered, and Zabidou is aimed squarely at moving that discovery earlier.

A fault identified while the mould is still open, or while the section remains in the jig, is usually a correction. The item has not been finished, nothing downstream has been committed, and in most cases no report is raised at all because no requirement was ever departed from in a completed item.

The same fault identified at dispatch is a non-conformance, with the hold, the disposition and the documentation that follow. Identified on site, it is a non-conformance plus a delivery, a return and a conversation with the customer.

Zabidou measures every item as it comes off the line and holds the result against that item, so a dimensional departure is visible at the point it occurs rather than at the point someone thinks to look. The same check runs on a precast concrete bed and on a steel fabrication line.

For a plant that is a straightforward trade. A correction logged on the shift costs minutes and generates no paperwork. A non-conformance costs the item, the hold, the disposition, the corrective action and a conversation with the customer, and the only thing separating the two is how quickly the fault was seen. Moving faults from the second column into the first is where the money is.

The comparison worth making is against systems that return an answer slowly, not against the inspector, because the delay is what turns a correction into a non-conformance.

Non-conformances are usually raised against a check in the inspection and test plan, they are normally closed out before a certificate of conformance is issued, and their rate is the other side of first pass yield.

What Zabidou checks on the line

Five checks run inside the production step, on every item that passes it. Each one is aimed at a class of departure that would otherwise be found at dispatch or on site, by which point it is a non-conformance rather than a correction.

Full 3D As-built vs As-planned

3D as-built comparison icon

Complete 3D measurement and verification of as-built output against a Golden Sample or design intent, for full dimensional compliance without stopping the line.

Set-out Verification

Set-out verification icon

Automated, real-time verification that components are correctly positioned before and during production, while the mould is still open or the section is still in the jig.

Surface Anomaly Detection

Surface anomaly detection icon

Inline detection of surface defects, voids and irregularities at industrial speed, fully automated and without manual inspection.

Key Dimension Measurements & Verification

Key dimension measurement icon

Precise measurement and verification of critical dimensions against a Golden Sample or the drawings, inline, in real time, at scale.

Digital Provenance

Digital provenance icon

Manufactured-unit centric digital provenance that automatically delivers the full audit history operations, financiers and customers demand.


The same fault, found at three different points

A departure does not change as it travels. What changes is what it costs to resolve and how much paperwork it generates.

One dimensional fault, discovered in the mould, at dispatch and on site.
 Found in the mouldFound at dispatchFound on site
What it is calledA correction.A non-conformance.A non-conformance and a delivery failure.
Who is involvedThe operator at the station.The quality team and a disposition authority.The customer, the site team and the plant.
What it holds upNothing. The item has not been completed.The item, and anything scheduled behind it.The crane, the crew and the sequence on site.
What the record showsThe measurement, against that item.A report, a disposition and a corrective action.All of the above, raised by someone else.
The green Zabidou inspection enclosure mounted over the production line at Vossloh Australia, with cast sleepers stacked in the yard beyond
A Zabidou sensor unit mounted on the line guarding at Vossloh Australia, above the sleeper moulds

Common questions about non-conformance

What is a non conformance in construction?

A non-conformance is a departure from a specified requirement. The item, process or document does not meet what the drawing, specification, standard or contract required, and the departure has to be recorded and dispositioned rather than simply corrected.

The requirement has to exist and be stated. Where no requirement was specified, there is nothing to depart from, which is why unclear specifications generate so many disputes about whether a non-conformance has occurred.

What does NCR stand for?

NCR stands for non-conformance report, the document raised to record a non-conformance. Some organisations call it a non-conformity report or a non-compliance report, and in practice the three terms are used interchangeably.

What should a non-conformance report contain?

At minimum it should identify the item affected, state the requirement that was not met with its reference, describe the departure objectively, and record the disposition decision along with who made it and when.

Most reports also carry the corrective action taken to stop a recurrence, which is the part an auditor is most likely to test.

What is disposition in a non-conformance?

Disposition is the decision about what happens to the affected item. The usual options are to use it as it stands, rework it to meet the requirement, repair it to an agreed standard, or reject it.

Using an item as it stands normally requires a concession from the party that set the requirement, since it means accepting something other than what was specified.

What is the difference between a non-conformance and a defect?

A defect is a fault in the item. A non-conformance is a failure to meet a stated requirement, which may or may not be caused by a defect.

A dimension outside tolerance is both. A missing mill certificate is a non-conformance with no defect attached, and a cosmetic blemish on a surface with no specified finish class may be a defect that is not a non-conformance.

Get in Touch

Ready to explore how ultra-vision can transform your operations? Send us a message and our team will be in touch.